The Best Toaster Oven Accessories

In today’s post we’re going to cover the best toaster oven accessories. 

Since a toaster oven often gets more use than a standard oven it only makes sense to have more cookware for your toaster oven. 

Toaster oven accessories can replace the standard ones that your toaster oven came with. They can also be good for additional toaster oven pans if you are making a few dishes in the toaster oven. You can prepare the meals ahead of time with multiple pans.

A mini toaster oven is a great kitchen accessory and it can save you a lot of space as well as money. One great feature of  a small toaster oven is that it  uses much less electricity than your standard oven.

So let’s get right into it!

The 10 Best Toaster Oven Accessories

Toaster Oven Cookie Sheet Pans

#1

GreenLife Healthy Ceramic Nonstick Turquoise Toaster Oven Sheet Pans

These GreenLife ceramic toaster oven cookie sheet pans are a great back up pan for your toaster oven. If you prefer eco friendly pans then these are the right fit. A great toaster oven cookie sheet pan without  PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium.

This bakeware for toaster ovens  will last longer if you don’t use metal spatulas or abrasive sponges. The toaster oven sheet pans are not too expensive, so you should plan to replace them every so often.

Check out our related reviews on the best compact toaster, if you just want a slim 2 slice toaster instead.

Using great toaster oven accessories like this toaster oven cookie sheet pan, will allow you to make small batches of cookies. We love to make a batch of hazelnut chocolate chip cookie dough, freeze it, then take out small amounts to make 6 cookies in our toaster oven!

Manufacturer specs

• Size 9” by 7”
• Aluminum pans that have a ceramic non stick coating
• Oven safe up to 450°F

What We Like

• The small size can fit in most standard toaster ovens.
• Easy to clean (as long as you follow the manufacturer’s directions and dont use metal or abrasives).
• The teale green color.

What We Don’t Like

• Hand wash only.
• The edges are bent and can accumulate water.
• They are not durable and will not last a lifetime. 

Summary

A great multipurpose toaster oven pan that will last long if you take care of it properly.

Toaster Oven Casserole Dish: The Best Toaster Oven Bakeware

#2 

LIONWEI White Small Ceramics Rectangular casserole dish Toaster Oven Bakeware 9×5 inch

Quite impressive this ceramic toaster oven casserole dish is.  Most toaster ovens don’t come with a deep dish ceramic pan, so this toaster oven accessory will definitely come in handy! Put it on your list of must have toaster oven accessories!

If you only get one toaster oven pan replacement this ceramic dish should be it. You will be surprised at the amount of creative meals you can make with just this one toaster oven dish. 

Please read the dimensions. The LIONWEI bakeware for toaster ovens is a ceramic dish that is small. Although this may not be a top bakeware brand is a great choice nonetheless. If you are looking for a toaster oven bakeware that won’t break the bank, get this baking dish!

Manufacturer specs

• 9×5 inch baking dish
• Ceramic dish
• 1 ⅘ of inch deep

What We Like

• Great for a casserole for one or two people.
• This toaster oven casserole dish can go in the dishwasher.

What We Don’t Like

• Nothing to report here. Any person complaining about this dish did not read the dimensions. All complaints are having to do with the small size.

Summary

The LIONWEI toaster oven casserole dish is great for a single serving. If you need a deeper dish for your toaster oven, get this!

Toaster Oven Crisper Sheet

#3

Cooks Innovations Copper Toaster Oven Crisper & Liner Set – Crisper Sheet and Liner each 9 x 11″ – 100% Non-Stick

If you need to get more heat circulation around your food, this is one of the best toaster oven accessories. You will get crisp food every time you use this toaster oven crisper sheet. Another thing is does is catch any crumbs and drippings so that cleaning your toaster oven is a breeze.

A crisper sheet can come in handy if you are making a toaster oven-baked potato.

Be aware that this toaster oven crisping sheet can slow the cook time.

Manufacturer specs

• Non stick liner
• BPA and PFOA free. 
• 11 x 9 x 0.2 inches

What We Like

• Dishwasher safe.
• Excellent product that does what it claims to do.
• A great accessory to complement  your bakeware for toaster ovens.

What We Don’t Like

• It is too large to fit in most toaster ovens. You can cut it down to size.
• You have to watch the food, because all of a sudden it can make it too crispy. It can happen in the blink of an eye.

Summary

Using a toaster oven crisper sheet can help create crispy baked fries, baked turnips, and baked sweet potatoes! A crisper sheet is one of those toaster oven accessories that gets a thumbs up from us!

Toaster Oven Pizza Pan

#4

G & S Metal Products Company OvenStuff Non-Stick Toaster Oven Pizza Pan, Set of Two, Gray

These nonstick toaster oven pizza pans are perfect for personal size pizzas. Unfortunately, these are not great if you don’t like to use non stick pans. The pizza pan is made with a steel construction topped with a Duraglide non stick coating.

Heating up a personal frozen pizza in the toaster oven has never been easier. The OvenSuff toaster oven pizza pan will also make cleanup super easy. The cheese will not stick to these pans so you don’t have to worry about soaking and scrubbing these!

Please take note that these are small personal pizza pans. They will not fit a large pizza pie, so if you are looking for small toaster oven pans, these are great!

Manufacturer specs

• Dishwasher safe
• Inner diameter is 7 and 7/8″. Outer diameter is 8″

What We Like

• Made in USA.
• 5 year warranty
• The pan cleans up easily.

What We Don’t Like

• Some people describe this toaster oven pizza pan as “too small”. Please read the specs before making a purchase. 

Summary

Having a nonstick toaster oven pizza pan can be a plus or a minus depending on what your views are for non stick products. The nonstick toaster oven pizza pan is one of those toaster oven accessories that you may not want.

Best Toaster Oven Cutting Board 

#5

Breville Bamboo Cutting Board 

Many smart ovens like the Breville come with their own smart oven accessories. The Breville Bamboo cutting board is just one of many toaster oven accessories. 

Check out our post on the best Breville smart oven accessories. We cover each and every accessory in depth with in depth reviews of each item.

If you have a kitchen with limited space then this toaster oven accessory can help mitigate that problem. Usually you cannot store stuff on top of a toaster oven because of the heat that it generates. Well this cutting board is specially designed to sit on top of a toaster oven and not get hot. It creates a special heat isolation area, so you can store items on top of the cutting board.

Manufacturer specs

• Heat resistant silicone feet
• 1.25 inches thick
• Comes in 2 sizes: 17.8 * 10.8 and 19.8 * 10.8
• Strong, durable bamboo that will not warp

What We Like

• This toaster oven cutting board can help you protect the top of your smart oven if you don’t want it to get scratched.
• Protects the cabinets above from the heat that emits from the top of the oven.
• It can create an extra storage surface.

What We Don’t Like

• We do not have anything negative to report about this excellent toaster oven accessory.

Summary

A cutting board that sits on top of your toaster oven can help create a kitchen that is well thought out and clutter free.

Toaster Oven Sized Silicone Mats: Best Toaster Oven Silicone Mat

#6

Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat, Toaster Oven Size, 7-7/8 x 10-7/8

A silpat mat is a non stick cooking mat made of fiberglass mesh and silicone.  A toaster oven silicone mat is a great toaster oven accessory to have on hand and will complement your toaster oven cookware.

A silpat mat is great for cookie making but expect a little bit more spread from your dough. If you want to try your hand at creating the perfect macarons in the toaster oven, try this made in France Silpat mat.

The intent of using a Silpat mat for a toaster oven is so that you don’t have to use cookie oil spray or non stick pans. Anything you place on the Silpat mat will release easily. One thing we use our toaster oven silicone mat for is to make small batches of cookies.

Manufacturer specs

• The toaster oven silicone mat measures 7-7/8-inch x 10-7/8-inch
• Made for 8-inch x 11-inchToaster Oven sized pan
• It’s made of fiberglass mesh and the highest quality food grade silicone
• The Silpat toaster oven mat is safe for the oven or freezer (-40° F to 500° F)

What We Like

• The non stick mat is easy to clean.
• Eliminates the need to use tin foil.
• Reduces waste and is an eco-friendly product.
• Provides an excellent surface for shaping, rolling, or kneading bread.

What We Don’t Like

• After a lot of use they may have a greasy film on them.
• A toaster oven silicone mat can hold the flavor of foods. So if you don’t want your cookies tasting like shallots then keep them separate.

Summary

A toaster oven sized Silpat mat can save you money in the long run. You no longer have to use non stick sprays or parchment paper. This is one of those toaster oven accessories that is a must have!

Toaster Oven Rack

#7

TeamFar Toaster Oven Racks, Stainless Steel Cooling or Roasting Rack for Toaster Oven Pan

Toaster oven accessories are here to help you have more fun when cooking with your toaster oven. Having a small toaster oven rack to place your toaster oven pan on after it comes out of the oven is helpful. No need to take up your whole counter with a large rack when you can use a toaster oven rack.

It will also come in handy if you are baking a small batch of cookies or muffins. You can easily release the muffins or cookies from their baking pans and cool them on this rack. The toaster oven rack allows air to circulate around your baked goods.

Manufacturer specs

• Narrow spacing gaps to prevent food from falling through
• Four feet on the bottom, this helps raise the rack off of the counter and promote air circulation.
• Dimensions: 9.7 x 7.25 x 0.6 inches
• 18/0 stainless steel
• Works great with toaster oven cookware

What We Like

• Multifunctional: you can place items like shrimp on the grill rack and cook them in the oven. 
• The toaster oven racks sit stable on your countertop and will not slide away like other racks.
• The perfect size for cooling a loaf of bread.
• Perfect size racks for using in a smoker.

What We Don’t Like

• Some users report that the rack arrives damaged. If this happens just return it, it is not a big deal breaker.
• These toaster oven racks are not heavy racks, but at the same time they are not light either.

Summary

A great toaster oven sized rack for cooling cookies, making jerky, or roasting vegetables. (as well as many other uses)

Pizza Stone for Toaster Oven

#8

Round Pizza Baking Stone 9″ 

Finding a pizza stone for a toaster oven used to be a challenge, but now they are available everywhere!  Being able to make a small personal pizza for one in your toaster oven has never been easier with this 9” pizza stone toaster oven accessory. 

Some toaster ovens will fit a 12” pizza stone, just be sure to measure the dimensions of your toaster oven to figure that out. 

Be sure to follow the directions and oil the toaster oven pizza stone before use.

Manufacturer specs

• Dimensions 9 x 9 x 0.2 inches
• Unglazed ceramic stone
• ½ to 1 inch thick

What We Like

• You can also use this toaster oven pizza stone in a camper oven.
• Perfect size for reheating a few slices of pizza.
• You can also use this toaster oven pizza stone on a grill to heat pizza, potatoes, shrimp, vegetables, or many other items.

What We Don’t Like

• You must allow the pizza stone to properly heat throughout before placing your pizza on it.

Summary

Using a pizza stone for a toaster oven is so smart. Your pizza will taste much better then if you use a non-stick pan.

Toaster Oven Rack Puller

#9

Joie Silicone Devil Oven and Toaster Rack Puller, Red

A helpful tool for pulling hot oven racks closer to you so you can avoid sticking your hand into the hot toaster oven.

With a unique slip resistant handle  this tool can help keep you safe when baking with a toaster oven.

It’s great if you have a pizza stone in the toaster oven and do not have a tray that you can grab. This rack puller will bring the hot rack closer to you so you can easily slide the pizza off of the toaster oven pizza stone.

Manufacturer specs

• Silicone 
• Heat safe to 536-Degrees Fahrenheit
• Dimensions: 1 x 1 x 1 inches

What We Like

• You do not need to use an oven mitt with this tool.
• Safely pull the toaster oven rack in and out.
• Fits in the drawer under the toaster oven, making it easy to grab and use.

What We Don’t Like

• Doesn’t have a hole on the bottom so you can hang it on a hook.
• Not dual purpose. Perfect for a toaster oven but too small to also use with your regular oven

Summary

Do you need a gadget to pull the rack on your toaster oven? The simple answer is no, but it does come in handy since it stores nicely underneath the toaster oven.

Best Toaster Oven Baking Set

#10

casaWare Toaster Oven 3-Piece Toaster Oven Baking Set 

The best thing about this toaster oven baking set is the mini muffin pan. You can easily make dinner rolls, muffins, personal pies, and so much more in this 6 cup small muffin pan. 

Quickly putting together vegan mini apple pies has never been easier!

The non stick ceramic coating on this toaster oven baking set is non toxic and  PTFE Free, Cadmium Free, Lead Free, PFOA Free and PFOS Free.

Manufacturer specs

• Toaster oven baking pan – 7 x 11 x 1.5-inch
• 6 cup – toaster oven muffin pan – 7.25 x 10.5 x 1.37-inch 
• Loaf pan for toaster oven – 9 x 5 x 3-inch
• Can withstand temperatures up to 450° F
• Ceramic Coating is FDA, California Proposition 65 and European Union Approved

What We Like

• No need for muffin liners with this toaster oven mini muffin pan.
• The pans are heavy weight.
• Dual purpose, this toaster oven baking set  can also work in a regular oven.
• Easy to clean.
• Will work great in a camper oven.

What We Don’t Like

• This toaster oven baking set may not fit in a mini toaster oven. Please measure the dimensions.
• After a year of use the coating might peel off.
• Some people received a 12 cup mini muffin pan instead of a 6 cup standard muffin pan.
• After a lot of use, rust may appear. Which very well might have to do with how people are washing the toaster oven baking set.

Summary

A great non toxic option for a replacement toaster oven baking set. Make sure to check  the dimensions of the pans against the inside dimensions of your toaster oven!

The Different Types of Toaster Oven Accessories

• Toaster Oven cutting boards. These sit on top of your toaster oven and provide a heat damper. It will also buffer the heat coming out of the top of the toaster oven. Great idea to free up counter space and use the top of your toaster oven as an extra surface.

• Toaster oven baking pan sets. Most toaster ovens come with one or two aluminum or non stick baking pans. If you want more variety consider getting a non toxic ceramic muffin pan set.

• Solid ceramic bakeware. Often if you are roasting vegetables in a toaster oven they taste better if you can roast them in a ceramic dish. Baking dishes for toaster ovens come in handy if you use your toaster oven a few times per week.

• Toaster oven rack pullers. These rack pullers allow you to pull out the rack and adjust or check whatever it is you are baking without having to stick your hand into the hot oven. Most toaster ovens have a bottom tray where this rack puller can sit for easy access.

• Pizza stones for toaster ovens. Having a pizza stone is vital if you often reheat single slices or make small personal pizzas from scratch. Either way a pizza stone is important for pizza lovers!

• Silpat for Toaster Oven. A silpat allows you to line your cookie sheet and prevent sticking. A silpat for a toaster oven is just a smaller version of the standard one. Some bakers also use it as a surface for preparing dough.

 

5 Benefits Of Using Toaster Oven Accessories

• Variety. Choosing whether you want to use solid ceramic baking dishes for toaster ovens or non stick ceramic toaster oven baking pans will allow you to create better meals. Adding more toaster oven accessories to your kitchen will all you to create more meals with a wider variety. We love using toaster oven pizza pans instead of turning on our big oven.

• More counter space. If you purchase a cutting board that sits on top of the toaster oven, it will automatically create more counter space for your small kitchen.

• If you use the toaster oven often, having a good supply of toaster oven accessories will make your life easier.

• The more toaster oven accessories that you have the more creative you can get with what you can cook in there. Most toaster ovens do not come with a muffin pan. So purchasing a toaster oven baking set that includes a muffin pan will provide you with a wide range of things you can make in the toaster oven.

• If you have more toaster oven accessories then you will save more energy because you will use the machine more often.

FAQs About Toaster Oven Accessories